Cheapest Brisket, Pork Shoulder & Ribs in Madison, WI
Madison has Bavaria Sausage Kitchen, Willy Street Co-op, and easy access to Kettle Range in Milwaukee — plus a Costco that consistently prices Choice packers competitively. Wisconsin bratwurst is a specialty here; the independent shops usually beat the chains on quality even when they lose on price per pound.
Prices below are pulled from real submissions by Madison pitmasters. Every entry shows the shop, the cut, the price per pound, and when it was reported. Prices older than 30 days get a stale badge; older than 90 days get archived.
Open BBQ Board — See Live Madison Prices
Madison Shops Tracked This Week
Bavaria Sausage Kitchen
Old-world Wisconsin sausage-maker · smoked brats, kielbasa, and specialty cuts
Willy Street Co-op (East, West, North)
Grass-fed beef, heritage pork, organic chicken · higher price, better sourcing
Costco (Middleton, Sun Prairie)
Choice + Prime packer brisket, pork butts, whole chicken
Metcalfe's Market
Local Wisconsin grocer · Choice brisket, weekly meat specials
Woodman's Markets (Madison area)
Employee-owned, competitive on chicken and pork shoulder
Sam's Club (East, West)
Members Mark bratwurst, pork shoulder, Choice brisket
Conscious Carnivore
Local farm-to-butcher shop · pasture-raised, whole-animal, worth the premium
Why prices swing week to week
Wholesale beef and pork prices move on packing-plant supply, feed costs, seasonal demand (brisket spikes before Memorial Day, ribs before the 4th, whole turkey in November), and store-level clearance decisions. A brisket at $5.89/lb at Costco on Tuesday can be $7.99 by Saturday if the pallet moves. Board's job is to make the current week's numbers visible before you drive across town.
Which cuts to check for Madison BBQ
- Choice packer brisket — the workhorse for smoked brisket. Look for $5.99–$8.99/lb depending on shop.
- Boston butt / pork shoulder — usually the cheapest smoker cut per pound. $2.49–$4.99/lb range.
- Spare ribs (whole slab) — cheaper than baby backs and better for competition-style. $3.99–$6.99/lb.
- Whole chicken — often on sale under $2/lb; the best low-effort smoker cook for beginners.
- Bratwurst (fresh) — regional specialty in the Upper Midwest; check independent butchers first.
Get Live Madison Prices in the App →
BBQ Board is free to use. Sign in with Google to submit a price so submissions can be attributed. Add a price from your local butcher and help your neighbors find it.